Before the Destruction: A Dublin School for Deaf Boys and Its Demise (photos)

by Tristan Hutchinson, guest contributor

Up the main steps of the building and into the hallway, four floors of corridors that lead to numerous rooms. Inside the rooms sit beds with sheets on, jars of hair and face products, old TV sets. Classrooms of books, teaching aids and chairs. When the building falls into dust, with it go the memories.

After the Famine, the Catholic Church, together with the Christian Brothers, established St. Joseph’s School for Deaf Boys in Cabra, on Dublin’s north side, in 1857. The deaf population of Ireland was of particular concern to the Church as they had received no religious teaching, and emphasis was placed on religious instruction through sign language.

St. Joseph’s played a significant role in the formation of the Irish deaf community. Here, boys were also taught trades such as tailoring and shoemaking, and the school produced many skilled craftsmen. Tuition through sign language continued until 1957 when the controversial oralism method was introduced, prompting a separation of boys based on communication ability.

After a series of media revelations in the 1990’s about child abuse in Irish institutions, the government set up the Commission to Inquire into Child Abuse (CICA), and, after a lengthy investigation, produced the Ryan Report. This report outlined hundreds of systematic and “endemic” cases of abuse of children in institutions, including St. Joseph’s, and found a culture of abuse that for many years government inspectors failed to stop. St. Joseph’s was the only school featured in the Ryan Report where parents had sent their children voluntarily.

In 2006, the Christian Brothers acknowledged that boys in their care had suffered sexual and physical abuse at the hands of “individuals,” remarking that sexual abuse was seen as a “moral failing on the part of the Brother in question.” Boys reported instances of rape and molestation by staff. Others were engaged in sex talk and were shown adult movies in their rooms. The Commission also revealed that this level of systematic abuse led to a disturbing trend of peer abuse.

tristan_hutchinson_5

The Ryan Report states that children were not believed when instances of abuse were reported, and were more often than not ignored. At best, offenders were removed from the school and sent to another, where abuse continued. Recent studies show that deaf children are more at risk of physical, mental, and sexual abuse, with some studies stating a risk two to three times higher as these children may not be able to communicate their experiences, or understand what has happened.

The CICA report contained allegations of abuse stemming from 1914 to when the commission started, and the intention of the CICA was to publicly name the abusers, but was blocked in doing so by a right-to-privacy lawsuit taken out by the Christian Brothers. As well as this, an indemnity deal between a number of religious orders involved and the government allowed the Orders to avoid paying the full cost, and an eventual settlement of over €400 million was agreed, with the Irish taxpayers picking up the rest of the compensation. The report also opened up and criticized evidence of State and Church collusion during the period of abuse.

In 2006, the Christian Brothers relinquished control of Irish schools, bringing to an end over 200 years of management that formed the backbone of Irish education. This year sees St. Joseph’s School for Deaf Boys demolished, making way for a new national deaf centre.

For some, the school represented an opportunity to develop and excel in a safe environment. Trades were taught and the school produced many skilled craftsmen. For others, it was a place of shame and brutality. When the oralism method was introduced, those who were profoundly deaf were segregated from others, kept apart in classes and in living quarters. It bred a system of fear into the lives of children who were seen as particularly vulnerable.

I started the project with the intention of documenting what remained of St. Joseph’s before its demolition.

tristan_hutchinson_16

Some spaces were stripped bare.

tristan_hutchinson_10

tristan_hutchinson_3

Dorm rooms empty.

tristan_hutchinson_8

And sinks taped off.

tristan_hutchinson_14

Other rooms contained years of relics, objects, files, and reminders of the past.

tristan_hutchinson_7

tristan_hutchinson_13

tristan_hutchinson_12

On the walls scrawled graffiti; chalkboards still had writing.

tristan_hutchinson_6

There were beds with sheets still on. Bottles of hair products and tonics.

tristan_hutchinson_2

The building echoed my footsteps, yet the past was tangible and loud in the silence.

tristan_hutchinson_1

I wanted to document all this before the building disappeared into the dust.

tristan_hutchinson_11


Tristan HutchinsonTristan Hutchinson is a photographer based in Dublin, Ireland. He’s currently working on a project in the home of his mother’s birth, Cobh, a small harbor town in the south of Ireland, which has one of the highest incidences of cancer in the country. You can see more of his work on his website or follow him on Tumblr.

We welcome your original reflections, essays, videos, or news items for possible publication on the Being Blog. Submit your entry through our First Person Outreach page.


Share Your Reflection

8Reflections

Reflections

Excellent post. The abuse rendered within is appalling and evidence of a moral corruption unfathomable. 

It's important to document places like this, the images to serve as forever-reminders of what happened, how low-fallen even men of God are.

Segregation holds no promise for anyone... it was ill-concieved from the start, as are all segregated institutions for peersons with disabilities of any kind.

Hey there, 
Good comment, of which I agree. Yet, St Josephs started as an institution to help the Deaf community receive an education. Even as an atheist, I appreciate that the school provided so much for many children: a chance in life, skills and the ability to communicate. It wasn't until oralism was introduced that children were segregated and, in the mind of many, the shadow of abuse and tragedy diminished all that was good.
Thanks all for your comments and feedback.


Ecclesiastes 1:9 What has been will be
again, what has been done ...

bible.cc/ecclesiastes/1-9.htm -
"That which has been is that which will be, And that which has been done
is that which will be done. So there is nothing new under the sun.
..."

Here in Michigan, we face a similiar demise to over 160 years of Deaf history as our state sold off the Michigan School for the Deaf campus and most buildings to  developers who are demolishing cherished icons for the rebuilding of a co-esistance campus of deaf and hearing (seperate) schools.  The state will then lease the building constructed for the deaf students back from these developers.

The MSD Alumni have fought "David vs Goliath" fashion to no avail.  Most of this failure was due to politcal decisions made behind their backs and the information kept unobtainable from them.

One concession they've been given is in the destruction of their old gym... it will be dismantled brick by brick, the brick washed/cleaned, and then reused in a parking lot that replaces the building...this takes place the first part of August. (this information conveyed by alumni blogger.)

Back about 10 years ago for the celebration of 150 years of MSD, I attened with my Deaf husband (class of '52) and was with a group allowed to tour the landmark FAY HALL (Mich. official seal is overhead front of this hall).  We were especially interested in the 3rd floor dorm areas where my husband had racked up so many of his personal stories of triamph and failures.  I video taped several senior citizens that day standing in their own rooms telling THEIR stories of life at MSD.  I also took many pictures (as you did) of the background, floors, walls, empty boxes with family names on them, lockers, etc....

Few have seen these pictures and movies, but now with MSD's history about to do another "turning" (they, too, were affected by the Milan Conf. decision of 1857 to proscribe signing), perhaps someone will find that my ventures that day in capturing a moment in time is worth preserving and sharing.

If you are interested in any of this, I'd be happy to discuss it further.

Brenda Dawe (certified interpreter for the Deaf/HH, ASL instructor)  

these pictures are very beautiful. i always lament the destruction of the past. thank you for preserving some of it.

Stunning post. Thank you so much. 

Do you have plans to photograph any other Industrial schools?

Regards

Ian

Hey there Ian, 
Thanks for the comment. At the moment no, am working away on other projects. But it might be something that I could revisit if the chance or idea arises.
Tris

The abuse was horrific! Yet I can't help seeing the beauty and quality in the building itself and the thought of demolishing it just contributes to the waste. While it holds bad memories, it also holds good memories and I'd love to see the building refurbished (cheaper even?) rather than demolished - testament to redemption rather than trying to hide whathappened.

apples