Statue of Gertrude Stein
Raindrops pour down the statue of late U.S. author Gertrude Stein in New York’s Bryant Park. (photo: Timothy A. Clary/AFP/Getty Images)

“You always have in your writing the resistance outside of you and inside of you, a shadow upon you, and the thing which you must express. In the beginning of your writing this struggle is so tremendous that the result is ugly…but the essence of that ugliness is the thing which will always make it beautiful. I myself think it is much more interesting when it seems ugly, because in it you see the element of the fight … the vitality of the struggle.”
—Gertrude Stein, How Writing Is Written

Naturalist and author Terry Tempest Williams used the phrase “the vitality of the struggle” in our interview to explain that she doesn’t have the answers to the broad rhetorical questions (e.g., “What do we do?”) people sometimes bring to her.

This phrase resonated with our senior editor, and Krista soon supplanted the show’s working title with this instead. Williams noted on our reflections page that this phrase is inspired by American writer and thinker Gertrude Stein. Williams writes:

“I have always held that phrase close. It does feel like poetry because it holds the paradox of our human condition.”

Share Your Reflection



All respects to Ms Stein but I'd submit that often when ispiration moves one to write, I've found that while the iron is hot the writing has a truth that spontaneity can invest the writing with.

Editing may or may not improve those thoughts, but who am I to quibble with Ms Stein?

The post is erroneously credited by some computer glitch but my name is Frank Luke.

also Beckett's "I can't...I must"

i find this post and this quote by Ms. Stein quite moving. it resonates so well with my own experiences and, as well, often in what we see around us in these days. i often feel it necessary to 'soften the edges' when communicating but several incidents lately within my NGO have shown that sometimes one must be quite direct and (what feels to me) rather blunt. i hope that i can find a way to do this without offending. this ties in, for me, to the recent posting on maintaining civility as we debate and discuss issues about which we are passionate.