Add new comment

I enjoyed hearing the story quite a bit. Occasionally I was a little surprised that some of the holidays mentioned were deemed obscure. Any children's book of Jewish Holidays published in the US in the past 70 years would have as much info if not more as given in the talk. And the Sefer Minhagim woodcuts often relate to local folkways and customs more than to general customs - (eating apples with honey is widespread on rosh hashanah, haroset differs from place to place but is basically the same- fruit nuts spices drawn from the Song of Songs among other places). sefer minhagim woodcuts will show a man looking at his shadow (headless) shadow for Hoshana Rabba - the seventh day of Sukkot where the Ashkenazi superstition/folkway teaches thatif one sees his or or shadow headless on that day, it means that one will day in the coming year (last day for repentnence in the "Book of life" scenario whose highlight is Yom Kippur).

It was interesting to hear the discusssin of the luni-solar Jewish calendar. It should be noted that the leap month occurs in the spring, and so Hanukkah always begins 60 or 61 days after the end of Sukkot = Simchat Torah where the reading of the Torah begins again.Since Hanukkah is eight days long, occasionally the first and last days will coincide with Shabbat. BUT - the portions read on the Sabbaths of Hanukkah are NEVER the story of Isaac. USUALLY, the reading for the Sabbath of Hanukkah is MIKETZ, in Genesis and this section begins with Joseph in prison in Egypt and Pharaoh is dreaming about the seven cows. Rarely (in 2000, 2020) the reading will be the previous portion, VAYESHEV, which starts with Joseph's story and his recounting the dream of the sun,moon and 11 stars, and the dream of the sheaves of grain bowing to him. And when Hanukkah covers two Sabbaths, Vayeshev is the first sabbath, and Miketz is the second.

As for the idea of prayer replacing sacrifices, this is a Rabbinic dictum in as orthodox a circle as you can find and goes back before the destruction of the Second Temple (an aside, the First Temple was not traditionally destroyed on the Ninth of Av but on the Seventh. The destruction of the Second was on the Ninth and so the tradition combined the commemoration - [2 Kings 25:8 for the first, but the text says it took three days aloowing the combination]). There are verses in Hosea and Isaiah which are the basis for the idea that prayer is a valid substitute for sacrifices (not only animal but grain/flour as well) - Hosea 14:2, and we will fulfill/pay the BULLS of our lips (Vulgate has calves, Hebrew has bulls). this is taken as an equivalency. As well, Isaiah, 56:7 - "Even them will I bring to my holy mountain, and make them joyful in my house of PRAYER: their BURNT OFFERINGS and their SACRIFICES shall be accepted upon mine altar; for mine house shall be called an house of PRAYER for all people." (AV)

The idea of animal and grain sacrifices makes sense when wealth is pastoral and agricultural - just look at our word "PECUNIARY" for an example. And for me personally, the image of the sacrifices can be helpful as a meditative focus. After all, in our country on thanksgiving we slaughter millions of birds - two sheep a day for an entire nation isn't much, esp as many of the sacrifices were the sole source of meat for the landless priestly class.

The sentiment and value we give to animal life doesn't make us more ethical in our dealings with other human beings - after all many cultures highly esteem vegetarianism and have also engendered massacres and oppresion of members of their own societies and societies which they've invaded. And the Jewish tradition teaches that the Egyptians in Pharaonic Egypt also held some animals to be totemic or sacred and looked down on herding peoples, such as the Israelites. Ibn Ezra, the 11th c commentator likens them to "Great India" where he had been told kine were esteemed. See - Genesis 43:32 (most commentaries), Exodus 8:25-27. The Egyptians viewed eating with the Hebrews (who were pastoral and thus slaughtered rams and bulls) as abominable, much like traditional Japaense with those who worked in leather, the E-Ta or Buraku-min.

In any case, it was a wonderful show and gave me much to think about. Thanks very much to Krista and all her guests.