Krista's Journal: Carrying Forward Sitting Bull's Songs and Memories that Keep History Alive in the Hardest of Times

April 19, 2012

I can't say that I knew much about Sitting Bull when we began this research several years ago. His was the final name in our first series of shows on the spiritual legacy of historical figures. We've delved into the universally recognized names of Albert Einstein, Charles Darwin, and Rumi. And we've explored significant theological figures of the 20th century, including Reinhold Niebuhr, Aimee Semple McPherson, and Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel too. This fall, we'll be launching a second series, beginning with the scientist and theologian Pierre Teilhard de Chardin.

Producing these shows has been extraordinarily rich at times and at others extraordinarily hard. None of them has felt more complex or more daunting in the end than Tatanka Iyotake.

The word "elusive" also describes the process of approaching the facts of this man's life and the meaning of his legacy. That is in part because of the complexity of this legacy and of the terrible history of the United States government's treatment of native peoples, of which the story of the Lakota on the northern Great Plains is just a part. It is also a function of the relative privacy and largely oral nature of the historical record of Lakota culture.

Sitting Bull (1885)Sitting Bull was a thorn in the side of the U.S. government that first gave the Black Hills to the Lakota, then wanted them back after gold (Sitting Bull called it "shining dust") was discovered there. He refused to negotiate or sign treaties with federal authorities; he didn't, decreeing from observation and experience that their promises were not good — and certainly not to be trusted over lands that he understood as a sacred inheritance. General Custer's army attacked, and Sitting Bull's troops improbably prevailed. Thereafter and until the end of his life, he was pursued as Public Enemy No. 1 by American journalists and politicians. I've read some of those reports; Sitting Bull was portrayed like the Osama bin Laden of his day.

After weeks and months of being steeped in what feels like this hidden realm of American history, I feel confident about the truth of that paragraph I've just written. I know, at the same time, that it is nearly as simplified as those newspaper reports of Sitting Bull's day — one side of narrative made up of competing and utterly irreconcilable points of view. In the end there was, to be sure, violence all around.

Pictographs by Sitting Bull's Hand: A Smithsonian PerspectiveSitting Bull's own relatives and people were divided over his leadership and his resistance to any partnership with the federal government. Members of his own extended family were implicated in his death. This is a wound they carry even today, layered among the many wounds they have carried forward out of the settlement of the American frontier and into the present.

In the end, Sitting Bull's mistrust of treaties was vindicated by the history that followed. He is not remembered in Lakota oral history principally for that, or for the victory at Little Big Horn. He is remembered for qualities of character that were invisible to press and politicians of his time yet that inspire and strengthen his people even now: humility towards the land, compassion towards living beings, and the ultimate sacrifice of his life on behalf of his people.

Of all I have learned that makes me ashamed of this history and my implication in it as an American citizen, I am appalled that it was not until 1978 — 1978! — that the American Indian Religious Freedom Act guaranteed the right of the Lakota and other tribes to perform their sacred rituals and ceremonies. And these were at the essence of Sitting Bull's life and legacy. Ceremony is the very element of Lakota spirituality and lifeways. SoundSeen: In the Room with Ernie LaPointeSitting Bull helped shape the vision quest and the Sun Dance. Yet even while his closest lineal descendant, Ernie LaPointe, was growing up, which is not that far away in our lifetime, his family lived in fear of speaking openly or performing these ceremonies.

It is very moving to hear from Cedric Good House, who lives on the Standing Rock Reservation where Sitting Bull died, how the vision quest and Sun Dance are now experienced as sources of healing, very much in the best spirit of Sitting Bull's memory. Cedric Good House brought his son to our interview and is carrying forward songs that keep different memories and meanings of history alive in the hardest of times. I interviewed them in late November 2009. As we finished and said our goodbyes, Cedric Good House wished me a "Happy Thanksgiving" — a blessing that warmed me and stayed with me for days, containing, as it does, such a long view of history in which true generosity can be obtained.

He also offered the image of the pilgrimage some of the Lakota make on horseback each December, in memory of Sitting Bull's death and life — from Standing Rock Reservation straddling the Dakotas to Wounded Knee on the Pine Ridge Reservation in southwestern South Dakota. This is painful history to know as my own. But I am grateful for it, and more complete. I'm delighted to know Sitting Bull by his real name, Tatanka Iyotake, and to witness his enduring teachings of humility, compassion, passion, and healing alive in our midst.

Recommended Reading

Image of Sitting Bull
Author: Bill Yenne
Publisher: Westholme Publishing (2009)
Binding: Paperback, 392 pages

Sitting Bull
by Bill Yenne

I consider these two books as complementary reading. Bill Yenne's biography is meticulously researched and gives you a detailed understanding of Sitting Bull's life within a larger historical and geographical context.

Image of Sitting Bull: His Life and Legacy
Author: Ernie LaPointe
Publisher: Gibbs Smith (2009)
Binding: Hardcover, 160 pages

Sitting Bull: His Life and Legacy
by Ernie LaPointe

On the other hand, Ernie LaPointe brings the gift of simple storytelling to the page through the oral tradition of his family and culture. Reading one account gives a richer sense of the other, and through this we gain a better understanding of "parallel histories" in contemporary American culture.

Share Episode

Shortened URL


Ernie LaPointe

is Sitting Bull's great-grandson and author of Sitting Bull: His Life and Legacy.

Cedric Good House

is an addictions counselor who lives in Fort Yates, North Dakota on the Standing Rock Reservation.